Criterion 6.5.5 Building Penetrations

Criterion text:
Penetrations of the building through which piping or wiring is passed shall not reduce or impair the function of the enclosure. Penetrations through walls or other surfaces shall not allow intrusion by insects and/or vermin. Required roof penetrations shall be made in accordance with applicable codes and also by practices recommended by the National Roofing Contractors Association.

Comments:
Installers must follow the instructions provided in the SRCC approved manufacturer's installation manual. In addition, installers need to be familiar with appropriate construction, roofing and solar industry practices.

There are numerous methods used for penetrating, flashing and proper sealing of building penetrations. The following are examples of proper as well as improper methods.

Listed below in Figure 1 is a standard pipe penetration and flashing method using a solar industry developed copper flashing unit. Note that the flashing has been completely sealed. The copper flashing is installed below the shingle. This is a well sealed, clean and aesthetic installation.

Figure 1

Another type of pipe flashing mechanism is shown in Figure 2. Note that the insulation ends have been butted to the flashing and collector.


Figure 2

Figures 3 and 4 are further examples of proper flashing methods. Note in Figure 4 that the flashing is once again concealed under the roof shingles.


Figure 3

The pipe penetration in Figure 4has been well sealed. Sealing material, preferably polyurethane or other acceptable roof sealing material, was applied under the copper flashing. This method also includes a cap which is soldered to the penetrating piping. This allows the piping and cap to move ever so slightly with the expansion and contraction of the piping. This prevents any water penetration through the pipe joints. (See the bottom right photograph in Figure 1 above for a close up view of the flashing and cap.) The piping is then covered with insulation.


Figure 4

In some cases, especially in multi-story residences with basements that house the water heater, collector loop piping is routed externally. In these situations, penetrations are often made in the side of the house adjacent to the basement. (This prevents having to route piping several stories through rooms within the house.) In these cases, special care must once again be taken to properly seal the wall penetration from insect and vermin intrusion. (As well as rain and snow.) Figure 5 shows a wall penetration. The penetrations will then be sealed with appropriate sealing material. Expanding spray insulation is ideal for these situations.


Figure 5

The following photographs indicate penetration and sealing methods that should not be followed.

Figure 6 shows a flashing method that will surely, in time, allow water penetration. The flashing has been sealed using the gunk method by which the installer applies as much sealant material and hopes for the best. In this case, the installer used standard roof sealing compound that will eventually harden and form cracks. This will allow water to pool and eventually seep along the piping into the structure. Also note the uninsulated piping gap as well as the loose piping run. Hard copper should have been used to place the piping run closer to the roof for piping run stability.


Figure 6

Figure 7 shows that the installer used a standard flashing boot and then modified it to allow pipe and sensor wire penetration. A section of PVC piping was inserted through the flashing to accommodate the piping and wire. Standard pipe insulation was butted to the PVC piping. Sealant was used to seal any gaps. A close investigation indicated that there were indeed very small gaps at the top of the PVC piping which would eventually allow water penetration. (From both rain and melting snow.) Eventually, the insulation will shrink and cause even more penetration points. Installers should use industry accepted flashing and not customize with what is on hand.


Figure 7

Proceed to the Next Transport Subsystem Guideline

Return to the Transport Subsystem Main Page


Return to SRCC home page

Please address questions and comments regarding this web page to WebMaster